Voting Closes: Thursday, 20 April 2017 @ 5:00PM PDT
To vote, first review the entries, then create a comment on this post using the following example:
| 3 points: first place model name by modeler name 2 points: second place model name by modeler name 1 points: third place model name by modeler name Participants in the challenge will receive a bonus point for their entry if they also make a suggestion for a future challenge when they vote. If you submit an entry, you must also vote: - You may not vote for your own entry. - Please indicate the username you use in the 3D Warehouse if it differs from the one you use to submit your vote. |
You may also make a comment, if you wish, on why you chose each model. Please also take a moment to suggest a future topic for the challenge.
Good luck!
3 points: Sundial by alferbilbao
ReplyDelete2 points: St Katharine Sundial, London by samothrace41
1 points: Cadran Solaire londre by Michael BAUDET
'Baby Gear' for next topic...!!!
Delete3 points: St Katharine Sundial, London, samothrace41
ReplyDelete2 points: Sundial, alfrebilbao
1 point : SUNDIAL, Payal Sinha
Next Topic: Night Scenes
3 points: sundial by Tyler W.
ReplyDelete2 points: Ancient Greek Sundail by Curtis N.
1 points: SUNDIAL by Payal Sinha
Next topic: highway
3 points: Sundiel by Gordon C.
ReplyDelete2 points: Sundial by Tyler W.
1 points: SUNDIAL by Payal Sinha
Next topic : food truck
3 points: Ancient Greek Sundail by Curtis N.
ReplyDelete2 points: Sundiel by Gordon C.
1 points: SUNDIAL by Payal Sinha
Next Topic: Grandfather Clock
3 points: "St Katharine Sundial, London" by samothrace41
ReplyDelete2 pointS : "SUNDIAL" by Payal Sinha
1 points: "Cadran Solaire londre" by Michael BAUDET
I think that Tyler, Curtis and Gordon are the same and unique person...
ReplyDeleteIn challenge 259 I asked a similar question and Curtis's answer was: "no but we are in a high school class together"
DeleteI have examined their entries and I can't tell. Curtis and Tyler posted their votes during the same minute which would be hard to do as the same person because they had to be logged into their blogger accounts Their modeling skills seems to be about the same but one uses more segments in their circles. One of the three seems to use a mix of Architectural and Simple styles for their models, one uses just simple and the other uses either Landscape architectural and simple. They all spelled sundial differently Of course all of this could be done to make it seem like they are different people. I don't know guys.
DeleteBut we can admit that they do not vote for the best models. They vote "between students", without taking into account the other participants (except Payal who is perhaps a student too) and voting rules...
Delete"Participation ManualV.5 :
Selecting the best model entry can be very subjective but here are some things to look for :
- Relevance to the challenge topic
- Cleanness of the modeling (see common mistakes tutorial on the blog) : lost lines, reversed faces, non using of components...
- Level of creativity and accuracy : complex or curved faces and model, styles, layers...
- Presentation of the model : using of textures, shadows, fog, animation..."
I agree with you mam.....voting should be fair
Deletep.s. I am an Architect....:)
Sorry to think you were a student. You look young !
Delete:)
me and my classmates are just having fun in our class. if u think this is wrong what we are doing then u can take it up with our teacher. Curtis N is giving more details.
ReplyDeletewe are three high school students. 2 seniors and one sophomore. we have a class at our school just for sketchup and we three are the most advanced thats why we do the challenges. We vote for who we think should win. We attend Graham High School in extreme small town ohio. If you want to investigate the matter you can get on twitter and look at Graham Local Schools and see all the videos we post. You can email our teacher Mr, Ebersold. His email would be on our school website. The is supposed to be a fun competition. We are not cheating...........
ReplyDeleteYou are not cheating and you really are 3 students. OK, thank you for your explanations. It was not so clear and other challengers already asked the same question.
DeleteGood luck and keep it up !
Tyler W. doesn't care to comment. he is busy working on new models for our class
ReplyDeleteWho cares if we dont vote for the best models. Thats your opinion. We are high schoolers why are you all making this such a big deal. Maybe we think we make better stuff than all of you. We dont want the same person winning all the time.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteif you have further questions you should attend a class. or cantact the school and investigate if this means that much to you. our principle sets in on our classes alot. He enjoys watching our students at work.
Address: 7800 US-36, St Paris, OH 43072
Phone: (937) 663-4127
District: Graham Local School District
Principal: Joe Hurst
me and Charles Rhodes are friends now as i see he likes Star Wars as well.
ReplyDeletemay the force be with u
Thank you ! :))
DeleteI can see things have been settled now. I had full confidence that the three of you students were not the same person after examining your entries and your 3D Warehouse profiles. People have cheated by voting the same votes with multiple accounts but never have they gone through the trouble of creating three separate entries under three different warehouse accounts. :) Keep up the good work and thanks for your continuing participation.
ReplyDelete3 points : Sundial by alfrebilbao
ReplyDelete2 points : Cadran Solaire londre by Michael BAUDET
1 point : Sundial by Payal Sinha
For a next challenge, I suggest a helmet or a shoe or a wind mill...
Next Topic: Romanesque architecture
ReplyDelete:)
Delete-----
ReplyDeleteVoting is now closed. Thanks for your votes!
-----